Value Investing Substack

Share this post
✨ Berjaya Corporation (BJCORP: 3395.KL) - Part 1
valueinvesting.substack.com
Equity

✨ Berjaya Corporation (BJCORP: 3395.KL) - Part 1

Radio show host: "What do you think BJCORP's shares are worth? Between RM 5.00 - RM 10.00?" CEO: "Yes. Closer to RM 10.00." Current share price: RM 0.25

Aaron Pek
Nov 27, 2021
Comment2
Share

Berjaya Corp's new 3-year plan sees reorganisation of 5 core biz segments
New CEO Jalil Rasheed poses in front of the Berjaya Corporation logo
  • BJCORP’s new CEO Jalil joined the company in March 2021, and has been public about how he thinks its shares are severely undervalued. The investment thesis for BJCORP is a turnaround thesis.

  • Despite looking like a conglomerate on the surface, >80% of BJCORP’s revenue actually comes from the Consumer sector - which dramatically increases the feasiblity of the turnaround, compared to a traditional conglomerate.

  • BJCORP was very badly run in the past - hence the base-case scenario is for them to simply return to industry baseline performance. No magic tricks are expected from the new management team.

  • If they can do that, the conservative 5-year CAGR estimate is north of 40%; while the optimistic 5-year CAGR estimate is up to 70%.

  • Did you know that BJCORP has listed long-term warrants? You can juice up the above returns even further, while adopting only marginal incremental risk.

  • In his short time at BJCORP, Jalil has demonstrated himself as a capable business operator, with a significant focus on prioritizing optimal capital allocation - arguably Buffett’s topmost key performance metric.

Company Links:

  1. Company’s information and financials

  2. Company’s investor relations website

  3. BJCORP’s listed companies

“You can absolute make the same amount of money in Emerging Markets like ASEAN as you can from more developed markets like the USA or China - because of the existence of significantly less market competition.”

Value Investing Substack

Value At an Unreasonably Low Price (VAULP)
By Aaron Pek

Value Investing Substack NEWS

Highly curated news on stocks, economics, finance and value investing
By Aaron Pek


In 1951, a mild-mannered young man by the name of Warren E. Buffett wrote an article in The Commercial and Financial Chronicle newspaper titled The Security I Like Best. The security he was profiling was none other than GEICO, the insurance company which exclusively served government employees at the time - contributing to its significant cost advantage versus its peers. Today, GEICO serves as one of the approximately dozen pillars within Buffett’s $600B empire Berkshire Hathaway, providing the long-touted insurance float which has been said to have contributed up to 50% of the entirety of Berkshire’s historical returns.

Warren Buffett The Security I Like Best Geico (1951)
1.12MB ∙ PDF File
Read now
Read now

While I’m not trying to allude to the notion that Berjaya Corporation’s (BJCORP) outlook shines anywhere near as brightly as GEICO’s did then, it is most certainly the ASEAN security that I like best today. The current share price can only be described one way - mispriced - where the presence of the Efficient Market Hypothesis (EMH) is completely absent. The bid and ask prices of its shares today may as well be set by a 5-year old chimpanzee throwing darts at fish in a barrel, and this is a sentiment shared by others as well.

To be fair, this is by far the largest small-cap company I have ever come across, for the simple reason that this company is actually a conglomerate - but whose share price has since fallen to small-cap levels. BJCORP is actually the parent company of all the listed Berjaya companies owned by the founding Tan family (‘berjaya’ means ‘success’ in Malay), as evident by the mindboggling complexity of its ownership structure:

The web of entangled ownership of the entire Berjaya Group (not only BJCORP) - taken from CLSA’s April 2021 report below (click this image to expand)
Reach out to CLSA Malaysia at the highlighted contacts above for the full report

As you can see from the chart above, this web of entangled ownership shared between all the listed Berjaya companies is an absolute nightmare to untangle. I’d like to take this opportunity to apologize to all my loyal readers for going MIA over the past two weeks - because the more answers I sought from this company’s financial statements, the more questions it begot; and I ended up tunneling into rabbit hole after rabbit hole trying to find answers for the new questions that kept cropping up.

In many ways, my learning experience when analyzing this company resembled my learning experience when I was first studying macroeconomics - visualized as trying to understand many individual pillars of knowledge, but where you needed to understand some parts of other pillars before you could fully comprehend the one you were currently on.

In the end, I decided that it was futile trying to develop an airtight comprehension of this conglomerate’s financials in a reasonable amount of time - and decided that I would just type out whatever I had already analyzed in Part 1, while leaving the rest for Part 2. Rest assured that I fully intend to make up my research report quota by the end of the year.

For the sake of visualization, Part 1 will compose the entirety of the bull-case investment thesis and its context; while Part 2 will do a deep-dive into the relevant listed Berjaya companies to provide further insight into the dark, arcane blind spots that might reside within its accounts, and figure out where the upside may lie. Without further ado, let’s get spelunking.


Introduction

Berjaya Times Square, located in the heart of Kuala Lumpur - Google Maps URL: https://goo.gl/maps/Vvse8wqRn1kG6qWn9

The investment thesis behind buying BJCORP’s shares today can be described as being a turnaround. For the uninitiated, a turnaround refers to a corporate exercise where new capable management is brought by shareholders into a dying company to revitalize it, and breathe new life back into its desiccated corpse. For obvious reasons, being an investor in successful turnarounds can be extremely profitable, as the share price of the company prior to the successful turnaround is likely to be depressed. But at the same time, successful turnarounds are quite rare, as poor businesses tend to be poor for good reasons.

As such, most investors tend to shy away from investing in turnarounds as the uncertainty involved is usually high. If you’ve read my earlier report about Why Value factor investing > Growth factor investing, you’ll understand what I mean when I say that investors hate uncertainty - because it makes the future difficult to forecast:

Value Investing Substack
Why Value (factor) Investing > Growth (factor) Investing
If heightened uncertainty in the short-term means that it is practically impossible to determine the future trajectory of share prices, then the answer is simple - only invest in stocks where all possible future outcomes are favorable! For the purpose of visualization, this nearly 7,000-word article is divided into 6 chapters…
Read more
6 months ago · 2 likes · 2 comments · Aaron Pek

However, I would consider BJCORP’s turnaround a little different from the generic definition of the term. When most people talk about turnarounds, they tend to refer to the sort of monumental endeavor which involves lifting mountains to turn a gigantic 100,000 ton ship around by 180 degrees in a split second - e.g. Pat Gelsinger’s effort to salvage Intel after losing market share to AMD for a decade; or Joe Papa being invited to revive Valeant after its infamous bust under Mike Pearson.

Compared to that definition, I think the more accurate way to describe BJCORP’s requirements would be “clean-up” - rather than “turnaround”. Rather than requiring some sort of spiritual reevaluation in the corporate ethos, all BJCORP needs is a little spring cleaning of their dusty storeroom. All the ingredients for success are already in place - the only change that needs to be implemented is a reorganization of the wares which are already sitting on the shelves, rather than requiring an order of a new batch of inventory. The reason for this is very simple - BJCORP used to be very badly run (for reasons which I’ll go into below), and all they need to do to get things back in order is to return to industry baseline performance, and give the existing business assets a chance to shine.

So if that’s the case, what has changed in the past few months to warrant such a drastic revaluation of the business? The answer is the new CEO Jalil Rasheed (LinkedIn), who announced his entrance into the company in mid-March of 2021. In the 2nd quarter of 2021, he went on a buying spree of BJCORP’s shares - and now owns approximately 3.6% of the company’s outstanding shares:

New CEO Jalil acquired roughly 3.6% of BJCORP’s shares in 2Q21

While Jalil’s resume does carry some substantial pedigree (he used to be the CEO of one of Malaysia’s sovereign wealth funds PNB), the successful execution of this investment thesis does not rely on the masterful capabilities of a Steve Job-esque genius to pull off. Rather, all it takes is someone with a good head on his shoulders, and has the baseline capabilities to operate as a CEO of a large listed company. In that context, I have ample confidence that Jalil is more than capable of delivering.

Click the above image to listen to this podcast, and navigate to the relevant timestamp: 35m 42s

Before we dive headfirst into the investment thesis, I would just like to leave you with something to ruminate over as we pour over the analysis of BJCORP. In mid-July 2021, Jalil gave an interview on the most popular local business radio station BFM. At the 35:42 mark of this interview (navigate to the 35:42 timestamp), the host asked him point-blank what he thought BJCORP’s shares were worth.

Jalil answered very confidently - between RM 5.00 to RM 10.00, and perhaps closer to RM 10.00. Keep in mind this is a stock which is currently trading at roughly RM 0.25, implying an approximately 30x upside if we assume the lower bound of that range of RM 7.50:

BJCORP’s founder Tan has also been on a buying spree of its shares recently. Click this image to visit this website.

I understand that the potential for conflict of interest exists in his words, but that is just an unnecessarily way-out-there share price target to provide accountability on. In fact, if Jalil was in fact trying to push the stock with that sentence, I’d wager that he actually failed to achieve his objective - by virtue of the fact that people will wonder whether he’s insane. Which means that there is likely some merit to his estimate of BJCORP’s intrinsic value. Also take a look at some recent crazy insider buying activity by BJCORP’s founder Tan Chee Yioun in the above screenshot.

If you want a bit more context behind his estimated target price of RM 7.50, I’d recommend rewinding back to a slightly earlier timestamp of the same interview. At the 34:07 mark, the host provides a summary of the entire interview, which adds a bit more color about why Jalil might think that BJCORP’s shares are worth 30x what they are currently trading at (3,000% upside). I’d highly recommend just listening to this insightful interview in its entirety.

For more insight into Jalil’s management style (by the way, he’s only 39), you can also have a look at his excellent Twitter thread here:

Twitter avatar for @jalilwordJalil Rasheed @jalilword
(1) Thread: I joined fund management early in my career. At that point, my first firm was small, I had many opportunities to learn & grow. It was not as structured so roles were flexible. Which is why I always encourage to start with small firm and learn as much as you can.

Rushdee @rushdeebhm

@jalilword Not sure if you've shared. But would love to hear how did you climb the corporate ladder so fast. To be a CEO at 36/37 is a remarkable experience. Was it worth it, to go up so fast?

January 17th 2021

1,701 Retweets3,422 Likes

Also to learn more about him as a person, check out this very classy recent interview with him in a local celebrity magazine:

Click this image to read this article

As I’ve alluded to earlier, the research scope of this conglomerate is so much more vast than your average Malaysian small-cap, that I genuinely do not believe it will be the best use of your scarce reading time to expound on the entirety of BJCORP’s financial context in Part 1 of this report. Instead, I will focus on delivering the investment narrative in Part 1 as efficiently as possible (this report is already 10,000 words long) - and then provide a further deep-dive into their MD&A and notes of their latest annual report in Part 2, for those who want more financial context to Part 1’s investment narrative. Given BJCORP’s share price performance over the past few months, I find it extremely unlikely that its share price will jump in the space of a week or two anyway.

Hence, the way I’ve decided to structure Part 1 of this research report will be as follows:

  1. Background of the company - to provide historical context until Jalil’s appointment as CEO in March 2021

  2. New developments since Jalil’s appointment, and how things are expected to change further going forward

  3. Jalil’s management style and his corporate strategy for BJCORP

  4. Financial analysis of BJCORP's financial statements - from their annual report

  5. Valuation

  6. Risk

  7. Warrants

When I’m done, you’ll understand why it took me two weeks to research this company and 10,000 words to type out Part 1 of this report.

(The above links which jump to the relevant chapters will only work in the desktop version of Google Chrome. If you’re using a different browser, please scroll to the relevant chapters below.)

While the entire world was falling apart from news of the new Omnicron variant yesterday, BJCORP only fell -1.92%. This is one of the key advantages of buying stocks at a super depressed price - the complete lack of downside risk.

Black Friday SALE! Get more ASEAN stock ideas like this and access to all our previous research reports for 10% off! Limited time only… promotion ends in 3 days!

Get an annual subscription for just $79!


Background of BJCORP

BJCORP’s segment results - as disclosed in their FY21 annual report’s MD&A

Value Investing Substack

Value At an Unreasonably Low Price (VAULP)
By Aaron Pek

Value Investing Substack NEWS

Highly curated news on stocks, economics, finance and value investing
By Aaron Pek
Get a 30-day trial for FREE to read the rest of this 10,000-word report by clicking this button!

I want to read the full report NOW!

As you can see above, BJCORP is a large company with a corporate empire that spans several sectors. Analyzing a conglomerate is equivalent to analyzing 5-6 different companies, since each sector has its own idiosyncratic characteristics.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2022 Daniel
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing